Why silent mode isn’t quite the same as showing up.
Whenever I sit down at a table for lunch or a conversation, I put my iPhone on silent and set it face-down.
I’ve always considered this a rather sophisticated display of good manners. No buzzing, no chiming, no sudden interruption announcing that somebody three time zones away has liked a photograph of a sandwich.
Face-down. Silent. Problem solved.
Or so I thought.
I’ve been thinking about this lately while working with my friend Donald Hanley on our upcoming book, School of Two Thousand Smiles. One idea woven through the story is deceptively simple:
What changes when we stop seeing children as test scores, attendance records, and little administrative challenges, and start seeing them as individual human beings?
It’s a question about education, certainly. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized it wasn’t confined to classrooms. Adults also have a remarkable talent for turning other human beings into items on a to-do list.
That got me thinking about something the philosopher Martin Buber explored over a century ago in his book I and Thou.
Buber described two ways we encounter the world. He called them I–It and I–Thou.
I–It is our everyday, get-things-done mode. We organize, evaluate, schedule, and manage. People can even become part of that process. We’re listening, but we’re also thinking about the next appointment, the grocery list, or whether we remembered to turn off the stove.
I–Thou is something different. It’s when we stop managing the moment and actually meet another person. We listen with curiosity. We put aside our agenda. For a little while, the person across from us isn’t competing with the rest of the world for our attention.
And here’s the uncomfortable part: A silent iPhone sitting six inches from my lunch plate may still have a seat at the conversation. Even without a buzz or a flash, it’s a little reminder that the rest of the world is waiting. My ears may be in the room, but part of my attention is apparently on call.
So I’ve started experimenting with a few small changes.
First, the disappearing phone. Instead of placing it face-down on the table, I tuck it into my pocket or bag. Apparently, even a sleeping iPhone has a talent for attracting attention.
Second, the three-second pause. When someone approaches while I’m working, I try to close the laptop or put down whatever I’m holding before responding. It turns out a person deserves more than a verbal acknowledgment delivered over the top of a computer screen.
And finally, the occasional telephone call. I’ve been replacing some of those endless text exchanges with an actual conversation. There’s something wonderfully old-fashioned about hearing another human voice. You can even detect a smile. Emojis haven’t quite mastered that trick.
I’m still putting my iPhone on silent. Old habits die hard, and I’m not about to surrender the convenience of the mute button.
But I’ve learned something. Silence isn’t the same as attention, and putting a phone out of sight doesn’t necessarily mean we’ve put the rest of the world aside.
Sometimes the most interesting thing happening at the table isn’t on a screen. It’s the person sitting across from us.
Perhaps that’s what Buber meant. We don’t always need another notification, another answer, or another thing to accomplish.
Sometimes we just need to look up—and see the smiles right in front of us.
I’m Patrick Ball. Stay curious, ask better questions. See you next time.

Comments